Donald Macleod considers the events and music which inspired Holmes to write four operas, culminating in the mounting of La Montagne Noire at the Paris Opera. In contrast, after writing a successful ballet early in her career and despite two attempts at writing an opera, Chaminade never completed a work in either genre thereafter. With Marcia Citron, Lovett Distinguished Service Professor of Musicology at Rice University, and Karen Henson, Assistant Professor at Columbia University. Chaminade: Callirhoe Peter Jacobs (piano) Chaminade: l'Ete; Sombrero Anne Sofie von Otter (mezzo-soprano) Bengt Forsberg (piano) Holmes: Ouverture pour une comedie Rheinland-Pfalz Philharmonic Samuel Friedman (conductor) Chaminade: Nice-la-Belle Anne Sofie von Otter (mezzo-soprano) Bengt Forsberg (piano) Chaminade: Valse carnavalesque, Op 73 Bengt Forsberg, Peter Jablonski (pianos) Chaminade: Ma premiere lettre Anne Sofie von Otter (mezzo-soprano) Bengt Forsberg (piano) Chaminade: Lettres d'amour (text Emma di Rienzi) Heidrun Blase (mezzo-soprano) Ulrich Bremsteller (harmonium) Holmes: Andromede Rheinland-Pfalz Philharmonic Samuel Friedman (conductor) Chaminade: Automne (No 2 - Etudes de concert, Op 35) John Ogdon (piano).